Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Richard David Greene's avatar

I'm on a confused planet where I notice that heroic thinkers as Bertrand Russell and George Orwell lived before anyone knew of a Global Warming crisis or Asteroids apparently able to have been the dinosaur doom. I also notice these minds greater than mine, barely noticed the tendencies of group-dwelling animals such as humans, to often collude to make some of the group into victimized status -- as for example the moment in Orwell's "1984" where Winston, forced by the overall group into uncontrollable terror, cries out "Do it to Julia" -- as if consigning a victim to a forcible sacrifice to save the would-be survivor. I am also impressed that, in this past three-quarters of a century, vast new ways to rescue planet and general kindness now exist -- but the capacities go under-utilized. Example? -- medevac helicopters or anti-asteroid rocketry or "red telephones" between nuclear nation chiefs to prevent accidental H-bomb war. I wonder: is such panoply of rescue -- a cornucopia that could include air force sized aerial firefighting -- is rescue left undone because of fearing of hazards or subconscious malignant hoping that evils will strike someone else. Sadly, great wisdom from the past, doesn't much apply to a world where perhaps the over-arching question is whether modern planet crisis should be met by modern planet rescue or whether to tragically accept to do nothing and hope the onrush of disasters will hit Gaza and Haiti or Cuba or Sudan or Ukraine and so on, and hoping more mini-pandemics will stay confined to Africa, while leaving ourselves to sit around healthfully toying with ideas and words, which is all I'm personally doing at age 79, here. History sometimes shows people in their thirties and early forties, sometimes combining to change the world, sometimes in kinder directions. I wonder if there's any such "prime-of-life" people out there? -- or maybe it's here, on the Internet, while I'm too much into my elderly grouch mood to notice?

i

Expand full comment
Tereza Coraggio's avatar

Very interesting post. Bertrand Russell, though, is an early voice for the Great Reset--you will own nothing and be happy. While being wealthy himself, he thought other people should let go of their possessions. He also had views on eugenics:

"Russell supported certain aspects of eugenics and did not believe it should be overlooked. Russell feared that the quality of the human race would deteriorate, so he supported certain eugenic practices (Ironside, 2006). For example, he wrote that so-called ‘feebleminded’ individuals should be sexually sterilized because they “are apt to have enormous numbers of illegitimate children, all, as a rule, wholly useless to the community” (Russell, 1957, p.259). Additionally, Russell encouraged those with higher intelligence to have as many children as possible in order to curb race deterioration (Ironside, 2006)."

He was also a member of the Fabian Society. Matt Ehret writes, "The most prominent founding members were Sidney and Beatrice Webb and George Bernard Shaw. This group was soon joined by various influential aspiring priests of the British Empire, namely leading Theosophist Annie Besant, Huxley protégé H.G. Wells, Bertrand Russell, Arthur Balfour, and the founder of Geopolitics Halford Mackinder."

I wonder how much we are manipulated by guilt, to not feel we deserve any security, much less comfort. Anyway, I've just been thinking along these lines lately. Interesting and thought provoking read.

Expand full comment
2 more comments...

No posts